These brown replacement straps are what we have in stock, but they will work without the eyelets we always used during production. Maybe you can find a way to put some in yourself. The original straps were brown, and that's what we have now, though for a few years they were red & black (above). There's no difference in performance. The eyelets eventually fell out of the Third Hand straps (though it still works without them...) and the elastic weakens after a lot of use. Pull off the rubber discs, tap the pin out of the side support with a small hammer and reassemble with the new strap. Your capo should work fine. The pin & discs and side support pretty much never wear out. If the side support breaks we have a few replacements in stock.